Recently while having a look at the horoscope of one of my friends I found that he had Mars in the tenth house and the lady he was aiming for had Mars in the seventh house. Now by definition he was not a Mangalik and the girl was a Mangalik.
In another case the girl had Mars in twelfth house and boy had Mars in tenth house but the relationship was rejected by the boy because the girl was Mangalik.
As an individual I do not believe much in Managlik Dosha. It is just a yoga or a combination, nothing else. Not that I do not give importance to it but I do not consider Mangalik or Mangal Dosha as single factor preventing the matchmaking or matching of horoscopes (Kundli Milan).
There are other things as well that affect the health of relationship in a horoscope. But since I am interested in astrology I always think about several aspects of astrology.
While analyzing such cases I often think why Mars in tenth house is excluded from Managalik Dosha.
Reason why I think this is simple:
Second and Seventh house in the birth chart along with Mars are the basis of Mangalik Dosha or Mangal Dosh.
Mars in the tenth house in the birth chart will aspect the ascendant, fourth house and the fifth house. All three are very important for marriage. The ascendant is for self, health, the fourth house is for sukh and mind and the fifth house is for children.
If the position of Mars is not good in the second house for married relationship, how can it be good for individuals with Mars in tenth?
Similarly it is the ninth house from the second. Means the support of the family is entirely dependent on the tenth house.
Why then do the greatest of astrologers exclude tenth house from Mangalik Dosha. May be because they think it will go against the glory of Mars in the tenth house of horoscope described in the ancient astrology texts.
Author - Archit
लाभस्तेषां जयस्तेषां कुतस्तेषां पराजयः
येषामिन्दीवरश्यामो हृदयस्थो जनार्दनः I
ज्योतिष सदा से ही मेरा प्रिय विषय रहा है. अपने अभी तक के जीवन में मुझे इस क्षेत्र से जुड़े बहुत से लोगों के विचार जानने का अवसर मिला. सौभाग्यवश ऐसे भी कई लोगों से मिला जिन्हें इस क्षेत्र में विश्वास ही नहीं था. फ्यूचरपॉइंट संस्था (दिल्ली) से भी बहुत कुछ सीखा और अपने पिताजी से तो अभी भी यदा कदा सीखते ही रहता हूँ. ज्योतिष अच्छा तो बहुत है परंतु इसमें भ्रांतियां भी उतनी ही फैली हुई हैं जिस कारण कभी कभी बड़ा दुःख होता है. नौकरी के चलते ज्योतिष में समय देना थोड़ा कठिन हो जाता है अतः ईश्वर की प्रेरणा से अपने विचारों को प्रकट करने के लिए और इनसे किसी का कुछ भी भला हो सके इसी हेतु लेख लिखा करता हूँ.